The fight for women's suffrage wasn't simply a battle between men and women. Women themselves disagreed over voting rights, the best strategies for achieving political change, and whether racial equality should be a focus of the movement.
The Suffrage Dinner Party is an exciting way to explore these competing perspectives. Students examine six historical figures, including Susan B. Anthony, Carrie Chapman Catt, Alice Paul, Ida B. Wells, as well as two prominent opponents of suffrage. Using evidence from their biographies, students arrange the guests around a dinner table based on shared viewpoints or potential disagreements.
Students then imagine a conversation between two guests, using historical evidence to construct realistic arguments and responses. Through these creative challenges, students develop a deeper understanding of the competing strategies, anti-suffrage arguments, and racial tensions that shaped the struggle for women's voting rights.
What's Included
6 Historical Biography Cards – Four suffrage supporters and two opponents, featuring their beliefs, arguments, organizations, and political strategies.
Dinner Party Seating Activity – Students compare perspectives and arrange the guests based on common ground or conflicting viewpoints, supporting their choices with historical evidence.
Historical Dialogue Activity – Students create a fictional conversation between two guests, using their historical positions and arguments.
Model Historical Conversation – An example featuring Edison and Tesla is provided to model how to develop a historically grounded fictional exchange.
10 Analysis Questions – Examine suffrage strategies, anti-suffrage arguments, racial discrimination, and disagreements within the movement.
Historical Thinking Skills
Comparing and contrasting historical perspectives
Analyzing arguments for and against women's suffrage
Examining different strategies for achieving political change
Understanding racial discrimination within the suffrage movement
Supporting interpretations with historical evidence
Grades: 7–12 Subject: U.S. History / Progressive Era / Women's Suffrage Activity Type: Historical Thinking & Perspective Analysis Time: 45–60 minutes Format: Printable, Paper-Based Activity

