This activity is more than your ordinary primary source analysis. Students start by sizing up five real jobs kids worked in the early 1900s: a midnight shift at a glass factory, a Pennsylvania coal breaker, a Gulf Coast oyster cannery, a Georgia cotton mill, and a city street corner selling newspapers. Each one comes with a Lewis Hine photograph and a job card packed with the actual hours, pay (converted to today’s dollars), and conditions those kids worked in. Before students can rank the jobs from most to least harmful, they have to decide what “harm” even means. Is it the burns and crushed fingers, the lung disease that showed up years later, or the school they never got to finish? That question alone gets a great class debate going.
From there, students read letters sent to Congress in 1916, and many of them are surprised to find that some of the loudest voices against child labor laws came from mill workers and a man who went to work in a cotton mill at 11. Then they turn to the reformers, including excerpts from Hine’s 1914 article “The High Cost of Child Labor,” and work out why Hine argued that child labor cost too much for everyone involved: the child, the family, the business owner, and the country. What’s included:
Reading: Child Labor & the Fight for Reform
Source Packet: 5 photo and job cards, plus 3 letters sent to Congress in 1916, with vocabulary support
Excerpts from Lewis Hine’s report “The High Cost of Child Labor” (1914)
Student Activity: 11 questions that build from basic comprehension to evidence-based reasoning, with charts to keep students organized
Teacher Guide: step-by-step directions and an answer key Grades: 7–10
Format: MS Word
Time: 45–90 minutes

