Can We Trust Everything Written Just Because It's a Primary Source?
In this lesson students learn about Nat Turner's Rebellion, analyze racial arguments used to defend slavery, and examine historical bias.
After Nat Turner's Rebellion in 1831, a white lawyer named Thomas R. Gray published The Confessions of Nat Turner, claiming to tell Turner's story in his own words. But how much of the account actually came from Turner, and how much was influenced by Gray's own opinions and prejudices?
In this lesson students will learn about the causes and consequences of Nat Turner's Rebellion. They will then take a step further by examining four excerpts from The Confessions of Nat Turner. Along the way, they'll identify emotionally charged language, question the author's motives and intended audience, and look for clues about how bias can shape the historical record.
Students Will
Explain the myths and arguments defenders of slavery used to justify the system.
Identify the causes and effects of Nat Turner's Rebellion.
Evaluate a primary source for bias, purpose, and intended audience.
What's Included:
4 page Teen friendly reading about Nat Turner's Rebellion
Four primary source excerpts adapted into modern language
Guided questions focused on bias, perspective, and historical evidence
Cause-and-effect graphic organizer
Teacher guide with answer key
Estimated Time: 60 minutes
Skills: Primary Source Analysis • Historical Bias • Evaluating Evidence • Cause and Effect
Sensitivity Warning
This lesson addresses slavery and the violence surrounding Nat Turner's Rebellion, including violence committed during the rebellion and the violent retaliation against Black communities such as beheading and hangings. These are mentioned NOT described in graphic detail.

