
Unit 10: The Last Frontier
1865-1890
Pioneers on the Plains
Great Plains Pioneers Lesson Plan | Grades 7-12
Listen to the audio version.
The year is 1870; it has only been forty years since settlers began crossing “The Great American Desert” on their way to greener pastures in Oregon. At that time most people believed that if trees couldn’t grow then the land wasn’t much good for agriculture. When the first settlers set eyes on the Great Plains they saw vast oceans of tall, yellow grass, swarms of buffalo, and a scattering of nomadic Indian tribes. They kept on moving.
After the Civil War people began to change their tune about the Great Plains. Especially when the economy tanked after the war. In 1869, an economic depression set in that wouldn’t ease up until 10 years later. A decade of hardship when farmers and business owners back east were seeing their homes and land repossessed by the banks. Many banks themselves had to close their doors. Times were tough. The toughest moved west in search of cheap land.

With the lack of trees, wood was hard to come by on the Plains. Instead, families burned cow dung. No really, it works.
Source: Kansas Historical Society
Listen to the audio version.
The Homestead Act
In 1862, Abraham Lincoln signs the Homestead Act. This law was designed to kill two birds with one stone: solve the nation's economic problems while clearing Native Americans off their ancestral territories. The country was struggling with economic depression and the government needed to encourage westward settlement to jumpstart growth. Meanwhile, eastern cities were packed with poor farmers and immigrants desperate for a fresh start.
Here's the deal the government offered: 160 acres of free land to anyone willing to uproot their lives and move to the Great Plains. The catch? You had to actually live on the land for five years, cultivate it, build a house, and pay a small filing fee (about $18). Thousands of families took up the call, loaded up the wagons or boarded a train, and moved to places like Oklahoma, Colorado, and Nebraska.
But this "generous" offer came with a dark side. The land being given away wasn't empty - Native tribes had lived there for generations. The Homestead Act became a weapon of war, flooding tribal lands with settlers while the government forced Native peoples onto ever-shrinking reservations. Every new homestead was another nail in the coffin of indigenous sovereignty.
The government said that if you wanted to keep your free land you had to build a home at least 12 by 10 feet. Some dishonest individuals tried to cheat the government to buy as much land as possible, hold onto it, and resell it at a higher price. One enterprising crook got around the law by building houses on wheels that were moved from one plot of land to the next. Others built homes 12 by 10 inches - big enough for gophers maybe but not humans.
By the time the Homestead Act ended in 1976 (1986 in Alaska), about 1.6 million homesteads had been claimed, distributing roughly 270 million acres - that's 10% of all U.S. land. Sounds impressive until you dig into the numbers. Only about 40% of homesteaders actually succeeded in sticking it out for the full five years and keeping the land. The rest either gave up, couldn't hack the brutal conditions, or were land speculators gaming the system from the start. And here's the kicker: the big land rush didn't even happen right after Lincoln signed the law. The peak years were 1900-1920, decades after the Civil War ended. So much for those romantic stories of brave pioneers racing west in covered wagons right after the war.

Listen to the audio version.
Life on the Plains
Anyone hoping to bring the creature comforts of life back east with them to the Great Plains must have been sorely disappointed. The Great Plains was no place for the weak. In the summer, you baked in 100 degree heat and in the winter the -30 degree temperatures turned your eyelashes into popsicles. Then there was the wind - constant, relentless wind that drove people half-crazy with its howling. Droughts could last for years. Grasshopper swarms could descend like a biblical plague and devour an entire year's crop in an afternoon. Tall prairie grass stretched in all directions for miles, with barely a tree in sight except along creek beds and river bottoms.
Most folks had already sold everything and turning back wasn't an option. The first thing on their minds once they arrived on their empty plot of land was building a house. This was as a new of an experience for them as it would be for us. Since trees were scarce that meant building with wood was out of the question. The other option often came in the most abundant natural resource available - sod. Sod is a clumpy mixture of vegetation and dirt that makes the land so difficult for wimpy plows to break through. However, it makes an excellent building material that keeps the house cool in the summer and warm in the winter. Relatively speaking that is. The walls were typically 2-3 feet thick, which provided great insulation but also made the interior pretty dark.
Plains farmers - known as sodbusters - got to work carving out bricks of sod and stacking them on top one another. Building a typical soddy required cutting thousands of these bricks. A door and a window might give some light but not much. The roof was also made of sod, which meant that when it rained, mud would drip down on everything for days afterward. A fireplace was built along the back wall that served as a kitchen and heating unit for the family. In your comfy new soddy, measuring maybe 12 by 14 feet, your family of 5-6 people would eat, sleep, cook, sew, entertain, and relax after a hard day of farming.
Keeping a soddy clean was impossible. After all, your house was made of dirt. Housewives tried their best but from their diaries, you can tell it was a never-ending battle. Inside was smoky from wood fires or more commonly burning buffalo chips (ahem dung). Insects and mice burrowed through the dirt walls and ceiling. Rattlesnakes were everywhere. People often slept with a hoe or a stick nearby to kill any venomous intruders.
If you think that living in a soddy was bad, wait until you hear about the rest of how Plains farmers spent their days. Farming took up the majority of the family's time. The sod had to be broken in the spring using a team of six oxen and a heavy plow that could weigh up to 300 pounds. This "breaking" process was backbreaking work - the prairie grass roots went down several feet. Once broken, farmers planted wheat and corn, though success was never guaranteed with the unpredictable weather. The fields had to be weeded. Men and women both worked the field. But women had even more responsibilities. From sun up to sun down there was a long list of chores that kept these people busy. Cows needed milking, wood chopped, water collected, butter churned, clothes washed and sewn, meals prepared, fences mended, tools needed repairing, the list goes on and on. Even drawing water for most folks meant a walk of a few miles to the nearest creek. When you weren't working on your own farm you were expected to help out at your neighbor's place. After all, they did the same for you. Now you get an idea of why farmers had such big families back in those days.
But one thing that most pioneers didn't consider was the intense loneliness of the Great Plains. Many pioneers describe in their diary feelings of intense isolation and sadness. Their nearest neighbors often lived a mile or more away. Life could be pretty dull. Children's toys were often sticks or logs that they gave names to. Often times the biggest social event was helping your neighbor build a barn or women might sew together in something called a quilting bee. With most people living miles apart church services happened when a circuit preacher came through, once a month if you were lucky. Neighbors might get together to play cards or board games but not often enough to keep people from feeling small and alone. The isolation hit women especially hard - doctors at the time documented cases of "prairie madness," a very real mental health crisis brought on by the crushing loneliness and endless work. Some people couldn't handle it and headed back east. Others went insane. Most just made the best out of a really tough situation.

Prairie grasses develop deep roots, up to 5 feet deep, that are adapted to the dry conditions of the Great Plains.

Pioneer homes were often small, poorly ventilated, and made of mud and whatever wood could be found.
Listen to the audio version.
Why It Matters
So why should you care about a bunch of farmers struggling to survive in dirt houses 150 years ago? Because the settlement of the Great Plains helped transform America into a world power. Those miserable soddies created the agricultural heartland that would feed not just America, but much of the world.
The land being given away wasn't empty. The Great Plains were home to the Sioux, Cheyenne, Arapaho, Comanche, and dozens of other tribes who had lived there for generations. The Homestead Act passed in 1862, the same year the Dakota War broke out in Minnesota. This wasn't a coincidence. As homesteaders flooded onto the Plains in the 1860s and 1870s, the federal government was simultaneously fighting wars against Plains tribes and forcing them onto increasingly smaller reservations. Treaties like the Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868 promised the Sioux permanent ownership of the Black Hills - until gold was discovered and white miners rushed in. The government simply renegotiated or ignored the treaties when they became inconvenient. The pattern was consistent: make room for homesteaders by removing the people already living there.
The environmental damage was just as bad. When millions of acres of native prairie grassland got plowed under, settlers destroyed an ecosystem that had existed for thousands of years. Those deep-rooted prairie grasses held the soil in place. Breaking the sod seemed like progress, but nature doesn't forget. In the 1930s, when drought struck, there was nothing left to hold the topsoil down. The result? The Dust Bowl - massive dust storms that buried farms and forced hundreds of thousands of people to abandon their homesteads. Turns out you can't just impose whatever you want on the land without paying the price.
Here's maybe the biggest lesson: the gap between American mythology and reality. We love stories about rugged individualists taming the frontier through sheer willpower. But survival on the Plains required intense cooperation and government help (like, oh I don't know, FREE LAND). The truth is, the pioneers didn't do this alone. Understanding this tension between the myth of the self-made pioneer and the reality of community cooperation helps explain everything from later agricultural movements to modern debates about government's role in American life.
Digging Deeper
Use the article to answer the questions below.
-
Why did pioneers move onto the Great Plains in the 1800s?
-
What challenges did settlers face when building homes and farms on the Plains?
-
How did the Homestead Act encourage settlement of the Great Plains?
-
What role did sod houses and new farming tools play in Plains pioneer life?
-
How did weather and the environment affect life for pioneers on the Plains?
Copy and paste the questions onto a Word or Google Doc
Test Page
